 | On Top of the World Create a player in Story mode (Chapter 1). |
 | Lucha Libre! Win the Mexican Gauntlet Match in Story mode (Chapter 1). |
 | Welcome to America Defeat James Storm in Story mode (Chapter 2). |
 | King of the Gauntlet Win the Gauntlet Match in Story mode (Chapter 2). |
 | Welcome to TNA! Defeat Robert Roode in Story mode (Chapter 3). |
 | Climbing the Ladder Win two Tag Team matches in Story mode (Chapter 4). |
 | 5150 Beat LAX in Story mode (Chapter 4). |
 | It's About No Limits Win three X Division matches in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
 | He's Not Phenomenal Defeat AJ Styles in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
 | This Is Awesome! Become the X Division Champion in Story mode (Chapter 5). |
 | A Heavyweight Price Win your first Heavyweight match in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
 | The Bigger They Are... Defeat Kevin Nash in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
 | Start Your Own Streak Defeat Samoa Joe in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
 | It's Damn Real! Defeat Kurt Angle in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
 | The New King of TNA Defeat Jeff Jarrett in Story mode (Chapter 6). |
 | Send'em Home Happy Perform a signature move to excite the crowd |
 | Highspot Risktaker Perform 50 aerial moves successfully. |
 | Don't Fire Eric Defeat Robert Roode with Eric Young |
 | Return of The Icon Play as Sting. |
 | X Marks the Spot Win an Ultimate X match. |
 | Detroit's Finest Win a Tag Team match using Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin. |
 | Mid-Card Contender Win 25 matches in any mode. |
 | He's on Fire!! Create an all flame clothing theme. |
 | Shark in the Water Defeat every wrestler on the roster with Shark Boy. |
 | Planet Jarrett Play against a real life TNA wrestler or someone who has. |
 | World Wide Wrestler Play 25 ranked matches on Xbox LIVE |
 | Jobber Nation Lose 5 matches on Xbox LIVE in one sitting. |
 | Underdog Wins Defeat someone of TNA Champion status on any Leaderboard. |
 | Best of the Best Achieve TNA Champion status on any Leaderboard. |
 | End of the Streak Defeated Samoa Joe with Kurt Angle |
 | Cage Was Robbed Defeated Christian Cage with Samoa Joe |
 | Ultimate X History Lesson Won 2 Ultimate X matches with AJ Styles |
 | The Fallen Angel Defeated Samoa Joe and AJ Styles with Christopher Daniels in an Ultimate X match |
 | Duckin' & Dodgin' Congratulations on being the biggest wimp. |