| Ammand the Corsair | Complete the "Pirate Poker" sub-mission on Shipwreck City |
| Angler | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Black Bart | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Maelstrom level |
| Black Cloak | Complete the "Defeat Enemies" sub-mission on Maelstrom |
| Black Pearl Crew 1 | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Black Pearl Crew 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Sea Battle level |
| Blue Coat | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Pearl vs. Kraken level |
| Bootstrap Bill Turner | Complete the Prison Fortress mission |
| Cannon Arm | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Pearl vs. Kraken level |
| Capitaine Chevalle | Complete the Port Royal mission |
| Captain Barbossa | Complete the Shipwreck City mission |
| Captain Elizabeth Swann | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Davy Jones' Locker level |
| Captain Jack Sparrow | Complete the Prison Fortress mission |
| Captain Sao Feng | Complete the Singapore mission |
| Captain Teague | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Prison Fortress level |
| Chinese Henchman 1 | Complete the "Debt Collection" sub-mission on Singapore |
| Chinese Henchman 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Singapore level |
| Cotton | Complete the "Rescue" sub-mission on the Isla de Pelegostos level |
| Davy Jones | Complete the Pearl vs. Dutchman mission |
| Electric Arm | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Elizabeth Swann | Complete the Tortuga mission |
| Female Warrior | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Isla de Pelegostos level |
| Gentleman Jocard | Complete the Davy Jones' Locker mission |
| Gibbs | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Port Royal level |
| Governor Swann | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Hadras | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Sea Battle level |
| Inmate | Complete the Prison Fortress mission |
| James Norrington | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Tortuga level |
| Lian | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Singapore level |
| Lord Cutler Beckett | Complete the Maelstrom mission |
| Maccus | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Male Warrior 1 | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Isla de Pelegostos |
| Male Warrior 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Isla de Pelegostos level |
| Mercer | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on the Singapore level |
| Mistress Ching | Complete the "Jackanism" on Tortuga |
| Mordillah | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Prison Fortress level |
| Palifico | Complete the Pearl vs. Kraken mission |
| Penrod | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on Tortuga level |
| Pintel | Complete the Isla Cruces mission |
| Pirate 1 | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Isla Cruces level |
| Pirate 2 | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Tortuga |
| Pirate 3 | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Shipwreck City |
| Prison Fortress Guard 1 | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Prison Fortress level |
| Prison Fortress Guard 2 | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on Prison Fortress |
| Prison Fortress Guard 3 | Complete the Prison Fortress mission |
| Quartermaster | Complete the "Gold Idol" sub-mission on Isla Cruces |
| Ragetti | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Isla Cruces level |
| Ratlin | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Sea Battle |
| Red Coat | Complete the "Jackanism" on Port Royal |
| Singapore Townsfolk | Complete the "Old Enemies" sub-mission on Singapore |
| Skeleton Demon | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on Davy Jones' Locker |
| Sri Sumbhajee | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Shipwreck City level |
| Tai Huang | Complete the Sea Battle mission |
| Tia Dalma | Complete the "Missing Person" sub-mission on the Port Royal mission |
| Tortured Pirate 1 | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Davy Jones' Locker |
| Tortured Pirate 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combat Challenge on Davy Jones' Locker level |
| Town Landlord | Complete the "Hit Combo" sub-mission on Port Royal |
| Town Musician | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Port Royal level |
| Townsfolk 1 | Complete the "Loot" sub-mission on Port Royal |
| Townsfolk 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Port Royal level |
| Townsfolk 3 | Complete the "Rum Raid" sub-mission on Port Royal |
| Townsfolk 4 | In Challenge mode, complete the Loot Challenge on Isla de Pelegostos level |
| Villanueva | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Tortuga level |
| Wench 1 | Complete the "Jackanism" on Shipwreck City |
| Wench 2 | In Challenge mode, complete the Combo Challenge on Pearl vs. Dutchman level |
| Wench 3 | Complete the "Face Slap" sub-mission on Tortuga |
| Will Turner | Complete the Isla de Pelegostos mission |
